Other Odd Poker Rules and Exceptions

playing_cards

In the game of poker, there are hundreds of odd situations that can occur and numerous arcane rules that may or may not apply to them.

When money is on the line, however, there needs to be a set, fair way to deal with all of these anomalies.

Plenty of players across poker forums, comment boards and in the real world are always looking for answers as to these odd situations, so the goal of this article is to create a definitive list of rules to resolve these conundrums.Without further ado here is my list of odd situations and Texas Hold'em poker rules.

All-In Situations

Two players all-in for different amounts: In this scenario, you take the amount of the smaller stack from the big stack into the pot, returning the difference to the big-stack player.

Short stack all-in against two players: When a short stack is all-in against two larger stacks, the blinds, short stack, plus the amount of the short stack from each larger stack is placed in the main pot. All players are eligible to win this pot.

The two players on the side are now free to play and bet as usual into a side pot, which only they are eligible to win. (This means there can be two winners in the hand - a side pot and a main pot winner.)

Multiple players all-in: When multiple players are all-in, you must make multiple side pots. Make a main pot as described above. After you've done that, repeat the process with the next-smallest stack.

Continue to do this until all stacks are accounted for. Make sure to keep track of who is eligible for what pots.

Balancing Tables

If you're running a tournament with two tables, and table 1 loses two players while table 2 is still full, you're going to have to move one player from table 2 to keep the tables balanced.

How to choose who moves is done by moving the player who is in (or closest to) the same position relative to the button. So if the open seat is in the cut-off on table 1, you want to move the player from the cut-off on table 2.

This keeps players from having to pay blinds twice, or not at all.

Breaking a Table

If you lose enough players to be able to merge one table with another (or multiple others), it's time to break the table. How to choose who sits where is done by drawing for the open seats.

If you're moving everyone onto one final table, typically all players, including those already seated at the table, draw for their seat. If you don't have seat cards, just use the deck counting lowest from highest, starting left of the dealer.

Can a Player Cash Out Half of Their Chips?

A player in a cash game has to play with all of their chips, or none. Cashing out part of your stack (also known as going south) is against the rules, and considered very poor etiquette.

If you would like to cash out only part of your chips, you must cash out your entire stack, and wait the set amount of time before taking your seat again.

This is known as recycling. The amount of time to wait changes depending on where you're playing, but I've never seen it lower than 30 minutes (the default online recycle timeframe).

Can a Player Purchase More Chips Off Another Player?

This is never a good idea. It's essentially the same concept as going south. The table loses the amount of chips the new player would be buying in for.

Always buy your chips from the dealer or the house. In a home game, one person should be in charge of all financial transactions.

Card Boxed in the Deck

If a boxed card (a card face up in the stub) is encountered at any time during a hand, the card is removed from the deck and shown to every player. The deal continues as if nothing went wrong.

If multiple cards are boxed, the dealer continues to remove the boxed cards until he reaches a facedown card to continue the deal.

If the stub runs short of nonboxed cards, the hand is declared dead, with all chips being returned to their original stacks as accurately as possible.

Cards Dealt Before All Players Have Acted

If the dealer burns and turns fourth street while a player has yet to make their flop decision, the play is temporarily halted. The dealer takes the turn card and puts it back into the stub, shuffling the entire stub sufficiently.

Once the deck is shuffled, and the player has made his final flop action, the top card is turned over as the new turn (there has already been a card burned for this street).

Card Exposed While Dealing

When dealing hole cards, if the first or second card you deal is exposed (the face value was seen by someone at the table), the hand is a misdeal, meaning the cards are reshuffled and the deal starts over (the dealer button stays in the same place).

If a card other than the first or second is exposed, the dealer continues to deal as if nothing had gone wrong. When the deal finishes, he give the top card on the deck to the player with the flashed card, and takes back the exposed card.

That card is then turned face up and shown to everyone at the table, and put on the top of the deck to be used as the first burn card.

If two cards are exposed while dealing, the hand is considered a misdeal.

Card Marked

When noticing a single badly marked card in play, first play out the hand normally. When the hand is complete you'll want to replace that marked card with a new one of the same value, or just grab a new deck.

If you don't have a new deck and are stuck with the one you have, your best bet is to remove the card from the game, making sure everyone is aware that the card is no longer in play.

It's better for everyone to know that no one has the card than for everyone to know when someone does have the card.

Dealer Deals an Extra Hand or a Hand to a Seat with No Player

In this scenario, as long as no one looks at the extra hand, it's folded as a dead hand, and play continues as usual.

How Long Can a Player Wait Before Choosing to Rebuy?

After a player loses all of their chips, they must choose whether or not to rebuy before the next hand is dealt.

In a home game there is room for lenience on this issue, just as long as the player isn't doing it on purpose to gain some sort of advantage.

Is a Single Over-Value Chip Considered a Raise or a Call?

By putting in one over-value chip without saying anything, it is always considered a call. For example, if the big blind is $25 and you're first to act, putting in a $100 chip without actually saying "raise" is considered a call.

The more lenient atmosphere of a home game means the dealer will typically ask the player what they actually wanted to do.

Player Misses a Blind (Cash Games)

A player can never come into the game between the blinds, or between the button and the blinds (unless they buy the button, see rule below). This applies when moving a player in tournaments as well.

If a player misses his or her blind in a cash game, they're not allowed to be dealt into a hand until the button has passed by them to the player on their left (it's treated as if there is no player sitting there). When the button has passed, they must post the amount equal to the blinds they missed.

For example, with blinds of $1/$2, a player who misses the big blind (therefore forcing them to also miss the small blind), they must post $3 to be dealt into the hand.

A small-blind post is always considered dead, meaning it goes into the pot and does not count toward any action in the hand, while the big-blind portion of the post is live, meaning it does count.

A player with a live post still receives option to check or raise when it's their turn to act in the hand.

Buying the button: Buying the button is allowed in some locations during a cash game. This means that when a player sits down between the small blind and the button, or on the seat where the button would be next, they have the option to pay both the small and big blind in place of the players with whom the responsibility lies.

This allows the player to play on the button, rather than having to wait for it to pass them the next hand.

Player Misses a Blind (Tournaments)

In a tournament, every stack gets dealt a hand regardless of a player being in the seat or not. When the last card is dealt to a player for the hand, the hands without players are mucked.

Players not present during their blinds have the blinds posted for them from their stacks, referred to as blinding out.

Player's Stack Size Less Than the Blind

When a player's stack is less than the amount of the small blind, they are automatically considered all-in in the next hand they play, regardless of position.

If the player's stack is larger than the small blind but smaller than the big blind, they will be considered all-in in any position other than the small blind, assuming they fold for their option.

When all-in, the player can only win the amount of their stack, plus that same amount from all of the callers and blinds. If the person has less than the big blind, they can only win the portion of the blind equal to that of their stack.

Removing Smaller Chips from Play

When the blinds increase in a tournament, eventually the smaller-value chips will become obsolete. Once the chips are no longer needed, they are chipped up to the next denomination.

First, make sure the chips are no longer needed (don't forget to check for antes in the future blind levels). If the blinds are $500/$1,000 doubling, you have no need for any chips smaller than $500 on the table.

Change as many low-value chips as you can into higher values and hold on to the remainder. For example, if you have ten $25 chips, you will receive two $100 chips and have two $25 chips left over.

Chip racing: The standard way to remove the odd low-value chips is a chip race (this is how it's done in all major tournaments such as the WSOP).

First the dealer adds up the total amount of odd chips on the table to determine the amount of larger-value chips up for grabs. For example, if there are 13 $25 chips on the table, they bring four $100 chips to take their place.

The dealer starts at the player to their left, dealing them as many cards as they have odd chips face up (if they have three $25 chips, they get three cards), until everyone with $25 chips has a card to represent each of them.

Each available chip is given to the players with the highest-valued show card, with each player being allowed to win only one chip. In a case of a tie in rank, suits are used to determine a winner.

Rounding up: To save time, some tournaments will round up all leftover chips to the higher value. Regardless of having one $25 chip or three $25 chips, you will receive one $100 chip in their place.

Suit Rankings

In poker, the official suit ranking goes with the official Bridge ranking system, which is alphabetical. From worst to best:

Clubs, Diamonds, Hearts, Spades

Turn-Dealing Mistakes

Turn is dealt without burning: When the dealer deals the turn card without burning, that card is simply treated as a flash card. The dealer makes sure all players see the card before turning it face down as the burn card, dealing the real turn as normal.

Two burn cards dealt when dealing the turn: In the case of a dealer burning two cards, and turning over a third as the turn, that third card is treated as a flashed card, and is returned to the top of the deck as the burn for the river. The second burn card is turned face up, since it is the valid turn card.

Two cards are burnt and two cards are shown when dealing the turn: The proper way to resolve this rare scenario is as follows. The second burn card (the official, should be turn) is placed face down on the top of the deck. The first up card (the would-be river burn card) is treated as a flash card and turned face down.

The second show card is the official river. It is now played as it lies on the turn instead. When action completes on the turn, the top card is turned over without burning for the river.

By doing it in this fashion, all cards put in play are the original cards that would have fallen if no mistake had occurred. There is no change to the results, and only one card gets exposed.

Please fill the required fields correctly!

Error saving comment!

You need to wait 3 minutes before posting another comment.

Sean Lind 2009-12-11 18:41:40

Brian,

In a situation like this the pot will always go to the guy holding Ace King. When someone turns over their hand before making the final call, it's either angling or an implied call. In a situation like this, where the other player told him his hand, he knew he was the winner.

Technically he should have said "call" first, or moved in chips, but turning up the hand like that won't lose him the hand.

When making rulings, typically the pot will always go to the guy with the best hand, and it's almost always the loser of the pot who finds some reason to complain. 10J lost fair and square, only a real jerk would try to take the pot on a technicality.

Sean Lind 2009-12-11 18:36:29

Matt,

Firstly the cut. In that situation things should have gone ice cold instantly. As soon as he got mad about you not offering him a cut, he's accusing you of cheating.

Maybe I'm just a serious dick, but I would have calmly told him just that "So you're telling me I'm cheating, that's what you're saying?"

He'll start backpedaling and try to talk his way out of it, no matter what happens at this point, he's going to be tilted/uncomfortable. This should make it easy to take his monies.

As for showing the card, that's not a big deal. I believe angling should always be allowed in poker, as the game was created with angling as part of the game. If you want to show your cards, then by all means do just that.

But in a casino, most places don't allow it. Some of the better card rooms will allow it, but only while heads up.

brian jones 2009-12-10 16:34:27

Two players in the showdown after heavy betting, commune cards favour a triple or runs Player A goes all in and at the same time says "have you got AK(giving A a high run) cause I've got ten jack (giving B a low run) player B responds that yes he has and throws them down player. A claims pot because B did not bet.B cliams pot because of A's verbal comments. who is right. thanks brian

Matt 2009-12-10 05:28:51

As dealer the small and big blinds are to my left when in a house game... this kid i bent over on the turn 4 wks ago filling in my K9 boat leaving him no life jacket got pissed lastnight when i didnt offer him a cut . So i said there isn't a rule in the world that says that you have to offer a cut. And i called out a kid that flipped over a card revealing a J while three hands were in play. Someone goes since you've only been playing a month i wouldn't be calling him out. You can't show cards like that can you?? ty again for your time

Sean Lind 2009-12-09 20:59:19

Matt,

There are no published rules about this, but there are some commonly accepted practices. Although some people (including my fellow strategy writer Daniel Skolovy) have the player in the small blind shuffle the deck, for the next deal, I consider this to be incorrect.

The whole point of having someone else cut the deck is to help eliminate the possibility of someone cheating. For that reason, the best way to operate a home game is as follows:

After you finish dealing the hand, it is your job to shuffle the deck. Once it's shuffled you pass it to the player on your left (the current dealer) who cuts it. The small blind then receives the deck shuffled and cut, ready to deal.

This way three people are involved with the shuffle and deal, and the actual dealer has nothing to do with the shuffle. It's very difficult to cheat when you never get to shuffle or cut your own deck.

Plus, this method is just as fast as having the small blind shuffle and deal.

The problem with having one player shuffle, the guy on his right cut, then deal, is it's very easy to manipulate a deck cut.

Even I (and I don't pretend to have any skill manipulating cards) can have a player cut the deck exactly where I want it with a very high percentage of accuracy.

Not only that, almost no player squares the deck after cutting, even if you don't rig the cut, it's simple to see exactly where the deck was cut, and then secretly cut it back to its original order.

So yeah, deal, shuffle, and pass to your left to be cut, they pass it to their left to be dealt.

Simple and effective.

Matt 2009-12-09 19:47:52

Is there any published rule w regard to you being the dealer and having to allow the person to your right a cut of the deck suffice to say as dealer you cut the deck to prevent the thoughts of a "rounders" moment. please email if you have a moment ty in advance!

Sean Lind 2009-12-07 20:34:27

Stefan,

It's a split pot. You have to play the best possible 5-card hand, since neither player had a heart, they both play the board.

Also, to win the pot neither player needed the Ace of hearts, they just needed any heart higher than the 5.

If one player held the 6 of hearts, they would have a higher 5-card flush:

KQ965 versus KQ954

stefan butler 2009-12-06 05:08:41

Right the biggest argument kicked off tonight there was 2 of my mates left in a pot and a K high flush consisting of K,4,9,Q,5 of hearts wason the table and one player had a K,4 both of clubs and one A,6 both of clubs ... But there was a 4 also on the table obviosuly the one with a king and a 4 thought he had 2 pair and the one with the A,6 just had A High ..... who would of won the ace high player or the one with 2 pair .... i personally thought it was a split pot because the best possible hand was on the table and no 1 had the ace of hearts which would of made them had the higher flush and obviously take the win ... theres a few hundered pounds on this decision so help would be veryyyyy appreciated thanks alot :)

Sean Lind 2009-12-04 01:46:21

George,

This changes depending on if it's a cash game or a tournament.

In a cash game the button can never be dead, so you make up for it with multiple big or small blinds.

If the person who was to be the big blind next hand busts, no big deal, you pretend he was never there.

If the person who was the big blind busts, then move the button, and have both the next players pay big blinds (big big). The next hand you'll have three blinds Small(on the button) small, big. This way all players pay a big and a small blind.

If the small blind busts, you must move the button all the way to the player who should be the small blind, making it 3 blinds again small(on the button), small, big.

In a tournament it's easy:

The button can be "dead". Meaning no matter what happens in the hand, the button will always move to the spot it was going to move to next hand. If the player who should have been the small blind has busted, you'll just have a single big blind. The next hand the button will be on an empty seat, with a small and big blind.

No one ever posts a blind on the button in a tourny, there are never 3 blinds, and no one ever gets to miss their big blind.

Sean Lind 2009-12-04 01:40:51

Colin,

Yes, player 2 has to show his cards. But, it's not quite that cut and dry.

All live poker rooms allow you to request to see any hand at showdown. The reason you are allowed to do this is to give you a way to prove that a player is cheating by colluding, by forcing them to reveal their hand.

So although it's in the rules that you are allowed to request to see a players hand at showdown, it's considered very poor etiquette to do so (since, the rule is to prevent cheating, invoking it implies that you assume the player is a cheat).

I understand that people use this rule simply to gain information on another player's hand, but I can not stress how much of an etiquette mistake this is.