The Poker Reporter Blog
Top 5 Comments from the Mouths of Fish
Created By: Sean Lind Posted in: The Poker Reporter Blog, PokerListed
Over the years I've heard fish say a lot of stupid things. Certain comments make me laugh out loud; others tilt the living crap out of me.
Some of this fish-speak is unique to the carp proclaiming it, while the rest is common enough to warrant a top 5.
If you've played a lot of poker, I'm sure you'll understand what I'm talking about. If you're still new to the game, don't worry; you'll empathize with me soon enough.
5) I knew you had [insert hand here].
No sir, you didn't know I had pocket aces. If you had known that, you would have folded your top pair on the flop.
Somehow these mouth breathers, unable to fold a clearly losing hand, justify their play by saying "I knew you had it." If they won the pot, they must be correct.
The other time you'll hear this is when a player's not even in the hand. Often it takes on the variation "He obviously had a flush" or "Of course he has you beat." Everyone's a damn genius once the cards are faceup.
If you're one of these fish, please understand that just because you thought of the word flush once in the hand, that doesn't mean you were sure they had it the whole time. Stop pretending you're Phil Ivey; you're not fooling anyone.
Tilt: 1
LOL: 0
4) I call you all-in.
This one baffles me every time I hear it. It's only ever said when the player is moving all-in him or herself. The other player has yet to act. These fish mean to say "I bet all-in" or something along those lines.
In order for you to "call," the other player has to bet first. You can't "call" someone else all-in. This expression just doesn't make sense; it cracks me up every time I hear it.

Tilt: 1
LOL: 1
3) You didn't bet enough for me to fold.
I can't tell you how many times I've seen a situation similar to this go down:
Player 1 raises preflop to $20. Fishcakes calls out of position.
Flop: A♥ T♥ 6♣
Player one bets almost the pot, $35; Fishcakes calls.
Turn: A♥ T♥ 6♣ [8♦]
Player one bets $60, Fishcakes calls.
River: A♥ T♥ 6♣ 8♦ [Q♦]
After some betting and raising, the two players get it all-in.
Player one turns over A♣ A♦ for top set; Fishcakes turns over K♠ J♥ for the straight.
After having called a raise preflop with K♠ J♥ and made an almost pot-sized call on the flop with a gut-shot plus a call getting 3-1 on the turn with the gut-shot, Fishcakes hits his straight and exclaims, "You didn't bet enough to make me fold."
This always cracks me up. Exactly how much would someone have to bet to make you fold your four-outer? But more importantly, why would the guy holding top set ever want a gut-shot to fold in the first place?
I love it when fish get lucky and tell the players they sucked out on that they were the ones making the mistakes. Poker's a funny game.
Tilt: 1
LOL: 2
2) It was suited.
Every time I lose to a random two pair from a hand like J-3, I kind of want to throw up in my mouth. More often than not the rationalization is "It was suited."
It's one thing to play a horrific hand into a raise, but it's another thing altogether to pretend it was a good play. Designer Glad bags dipped in designer perfume won't change the fact that what's inside is still garbage.
Please keep playing these hands against me; just don't pretend it's a smart play because it's suited. That tilts the hell out of me.
Tilt: 2
LOL: 2
1) Thank you.
Having a player say thank you after winning a pot off me makes me want to choke them. That's not a metaphor; I literally want to choke them. Saying thank you after winning a pot is best described as "twisting the knife."

Hearing someone say thank you is even more upsetting if the player sucked out to get the pot in the first place.
What are you thanking me for? I didn't give you the horseshoe you have stuck up your ... sleeve.
An even more tilting variation of the thank you is the online "TY." The only thing more enraging than ego and smugness is anonymous ego and smugness.
Other than slow-rolling, I seriously don't think anything tilts me more than someone saying thank you.
Tilt: 3
LOL: 2
Tilt takes the win of 3 to 2, scientifically proving that on average fish are more tilt-inducing than humorous (you can't argue with science).
The No. 1 remedy for tilt is taking down large pots. So when fish tilt you, respond by felting them. Once you see them reach into their wallets, I promise you'll feel much better.
Great minds think alike, my friend over at The Grand Slam Poker Source wrote a similar blog, check his out for more donk-a-larity: Top Ten Things I Like Hearing From My Opponents
More Poker Top 5 Lists:
Bloggers
-
- WSOP Blog
WSOP 2010 news, live blogging, interviews, parties and side action from Las Vegas.
-
- The Poker Reporter Blog
Poker news, gossip, parties, donkstrikery and functioning illiteracy with the PL.com crew!
-
Recent Posts
- How to Host the Perfect Poker Home Game: Odd Rules and Exceptions
- How to Host the Perfect Poker Home Game: More Games = More Gamble
- How to Host the Perfect Poker Home Game: Protect Your Game from Cheaters
- Top 12 Worst Poker Etiquette Mistakes (Infographic)
- How to Host the Perfect Poker Home Game: How to Beat Your Friends
-
- The Guest Blog
A menagerie of poker pros, celebrities, poker writers and industry figures.
-
- Positively Nerd Street
Pr0n for the poker nerd. Hardware, software, gadgets, etc; like poker, but from the future.
-
- Matt Stout's Allinat420 Blog
Online poker grinding and live tournament action with Matt “All In At 4:20” Stout.
-
- Jason Mercier Poker Blog
Million-dollar scores and the worldwide poker tournament circuit with Jason Mercier.
-
- Courtney Gee Poker Blog
Courtney Gee says goodbye to 9-5 jobs through the magic of poker.
-
- Matt ADZ124 Marafioti's Blog
High-stakes cash, live tournaments and luxury lifestyle with Matt "ADZ124" Marafioti
Comments
16pokerworld
2010-03-05Very good article, Sean
KC
2009-04-01Hey, Sean,
Great article. Check out your Twitter messages regarding a couple of articles you may find interesting.
@Gobbs
Sean Lind
2009-03-17You're assuming I'd be willing to stack off with one pair. I'll take my ability to fold one pair + 70% pre-flop equity against your J6 all day long.
But you're missing one very important part of that topic. That topic is talking about players who are playing the hand only for the reason that it was suited.
A good player looking to mix it up and be un-predictable will be playing the hand for implied odds, advertising and unpredictability. When playing for these reasons, the hand is irrelevant, meaning it doesn't matter to them if it's suited, connected or not.
Krikkit
2009-03-17I actually think that the writer's comment "Please keep playing these hands against me" is the most common fish-line, when the fish loses 100bb on a J56-board with AJ against, for instance J6 suited. Am I wrong?
buddhaboarder
2009-03-03good article Sean. nothing wrong with venting about suckouts. better here than tilting while playing. suckouts will always happen, we just have to keep in mind that it's our nature to dwell on the negative and not pay as much attention to the positive. going down a buy-in has ten times the effect on us than going up a buy-in.
ihazkaroz
2009-03-03well to me this text was just too stupid not to comment on. The author`s attitude towards everything he conciders "fishy" reminds me of an angry teenager. Sorry if I "trash talked" you`r idol wrdemup.
wrdemup
2009-03-03seems to me like the only "over-serious lameass" would be the guy goes out of his way to trash talk the author for writing a NON-serious humorous poker blog. Im left wondering who actually needs to grow up.
meanwhile, the author laughs his way to the bank after another week of "hard" work as a poker writer. GG sean!
david
2009-03-01the other refers only to live poker - when the flop comes and the guy next to you proclaims 'great fold'
neither makes me laugh or go on tilt though. just makes me look at his chips :)
Sean Lind
2009-02-28Wow, you read my soul. Nice call
ihazkaroz
2009-02-28after reading the whole article my impression of the author is quite frankly this: over-serious lameass without a girlfriend, who`s propably that annoying person in the table, tilting about how bad other people play in his opinion (which of course takes place after he lost a pot).
lol grow up
Sean Lind
2009-02-28I just came across a blog that has one major area of fishspeek that I didn't mention.
Bad Beat stories.
NO ONE wants to hear your bad beat story, not your mom, not the dealer, and not the guy sitting next to you.
anyways a funny blog for sure:
Check it out: <a href="http://redbullandpoker.blogspot.com/2009/01/funniest-things-overheard-in-poker-room.html">RedbullandPoker</a>
Zyg0tic
2009-02-27ahhhhhahahhahahahhahah
ty tilts me so hard
Ethos
2009-02-27Nice article Sean.
I have one more to add though which is hilarious and sometimes make me not just lol,rofl.
I play a lot of poker online and I see a lot of times a fish type in chatbox after hand is mucked something like "jj?" or "nice hand jj".They do it usually if they fold that hand.I mean come on,the way the hand is played has nothing to do with jj. But they say the opponent exactly has jj.I don't why jj always comes in their mind.
I used to get a lot on tilt from the comments you mentioned but not anymore and I have a lot of control. But the donks,especially the bad donks coming in plenty these days,the things they say take the crap out of me. I hope you do an article like this someday on those donks.
Sean Lind
2009-02-27I LOL'd Astro, I have to say I'm no poker saint, anyone who plays against me will protest to that.
But next time you find yourself in that situation (it will happen again), just stay quiet, or if someone asks you "HOW DID YOU CALL A RAISE WITH RAGS?", just look at him, while stacking his chips, and say "yeah, I'm not very good".
90% guaranteed to put him on tilt.
astro
2009-02-27Well , what can I say. I'm still working on my discipline when I play live poker and...
The other day I had position over a raise to £10 from the small blind (playing £1/2) and two other called so did I with J-5 suited.
I don't normally play that hand but as I said I'm still working on my discipline , I was bored of folding and card dead , etc.
Anyway I ended up winning a big pot against the AK from the raiser on a K-J-5 board.
I kind of did not know what to say and I'm afraid at some point I SAID IT MYSELF :
IT WAS SUITED :-(
EricA
2009-02-27Nice to see I am not the only one feeling this way. But what poker would be without these guys and their superior play ?
TY (for LOL)